Should Christians celebrate Halloween? For many Christian parents, Halloween raises difficult questions about faith, culture, and biblical convictions. Is trick-or-treating harmless fun, or are certain Halloween traditions incompatible with following Jesus? And how should families respond when other Christians reach different conclusions?
In this episode of Upside-Down Parenting, hosts Matt Jones and Janel Greig join Elizabeth Urbanowicz, founder of Foundation Worldview, to explore how parents can approach Halloween with biblical wisdom and discernment. Together, they discuss what Scripture clearly teaches, how to distinguish biblical commands from matters of conscience, and how to navigate disagreements with grace.
They also share practical ways to help children think critically about Halloween traditions, understand their family’s convictions, and use the holiday to show Christ’s love to their neighbors.
Whether your family celebrates Halloween or chooses not to participate, this conversation will encourage you to make thoughtful, biblically informed decisions while helping your children develop a lasting Christian worldview.
Learn more about Elizabeth Urbanowicz and Foundation Worldview: https://foundationworldview.com
- Recommended Resources
- Footnotes
- Foundation Worldview
- Loving God with All Your Mind—Elizabeth George
- A Christian Response to the Occult—Christopher L. Reese
Note: External links in this post are provided as a convenience for informational purposes only and do not constitute an endorsement or approval by Summit Ministries of any products, services, or opinions expressed. As an Amazon Associate, Summit Ministries may earn from qualifying purchases made through Amazon links.
Episode 68: Summary & Transcript
Disclaimer: Please note that this is an automatically generated transcript. Although the transcription is largely accurate, it may be incomplete or inaccurate in some cases due to inaudible passages or transcription errors.
Episode Summary
Christian author and apologist Elizabeth Urbanowicz joins Upside Down Parenting to unpack one of the most divisive topics in Christian parenting circles. Drawing from biblical principles, she helps families distinguish between explicit scriptural commands, applicable biblical principles, and matters of conscience when it comes to Halloween—offering practical wisdom for teaching children discernment without legalism or condemnation.
Episode Transcript
Janel Greig (00:00):
Costumes, candy, haunted houses, and trick-or-treating. For many families, Halloween is simply a night of fun and festivities, but for Christian parents, the holiday can actually raise some difficult questions. Should Christians celebrate Halloween? Are we participating in harmless traditions or are we embracing something that conflicts with our faith? And what do we do when other Christian families reach different conclusions?
Today, we are joined by Elizabeth Urbanowicz, founder of Foundation Worldview, to explore what scripture says about this topic, how to navigate matters of conscience, and how parents can help their children develop biblical discernment in a complicated culture. Welcome to Upside Down Parenting, Elizabeth.
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (00:44):
Oh, thanks so much for having me on today, guys. I’m really excited to chat with you.
Janel Greig (00:49):
We’re very gracious for you spending some time with us. And listeners, if you are not familiar with Elizabeth and her ministry that the Lord has placed her in front of, I highly recommend you get out there, check out Foundation Worldview. There’s curriculum, she’s written books, webinars, podcasts, and even book clubs. So great resources for equipping parents.
Elizabeth, Halloween can be quite a topic among Christian families and is actually one of these topics as we’re in this season that can actually cause division. We see it right now occurring online. So to help frame the conversation today, what do you think parents sometimes get wrong about approaching Halloween, and maybe what are some of the things that parents actually get right?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (01:34):
Yeah, that’s a really good question. And I think you mentioned, Janelle, the division that we see online, and I think it’s really important to remember that God has designed us as embodied beings. And so online communication can very easily go off the rail.
So my first recommendation is if you’re spending a lot of time online talking about this, get offline, talk with your spouse about it, talk with your brothers and sisters in the church about it, but don’t engage in really heated debates online. I don’t think that’s how God has designed us unless that’s a specific ministry that he has called you to.
Janel Greig (02:03):
Great advice.
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (02:05):
In your life. But I think when we’re thinking about a topic like Halloween, most Christian parents come to the table with really strong opinions on it. And then some are just like, “I don’t know. I don’t really know what’s the right thing to do.”
And I think that one thing that we get wrong is that we tend to view all issues as issues that are clearly outlined in scripture, where that’s not true about every single issue. There are issues that either scripture expressly commands or forbids. There are issues where there’s not an explicit command, but there are biblical principles we can apply. And then there are topics that are just matters of conscience.
And so I think a lot of times in the Halloween discussion, we tend to lump everything together and think that it has to fit in just one of these categories where there are some parts of Halloween that specifically go against what God has commanded or forbidden in scripture.
(03:01):
Then there are parts of Halloween that biblical principles apply to, and then there are parts of Halloween that are just matters of conscience. So I think if we can take a step back from heated debates and just start to think clearly and biblically about, what am I thinking about?
Am I thinking about my five-year-old daughter going out in a princess dress to get candy from the neighbor? Am I thinking about my 14-year-old going to the “House of Blood” haunted house with his friends? Those are two vastly different issues. So that’s one thing I think parents need to start thinking clearly about is what specifically is the issue we are wrestling with in our family right now.
Dr. Matt Jones (03:36):
Good. And I think that’s a great articulation of the three approaches, but is there anything else that really makes it so divisive? Because this really is teaching at Christian college, I’ll be in a classroom and I’ll teach, say how many guys grew up putting on costumes on Halloween? And it’s about half. And so other than the three things you mentioned, why is it so divisive?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (04:00):
Yes. Well, I think there’s two main reasons for that. The first one is that a lot of what Halloween has to do with is evil and witchcraft, which is specifically forbidden for us to participate in scripture. We’re told both in the Old Testament and the New Testament that we’re supposed to avoid witchcraft and sorcery. And so a lot of what Halloween has to do with is just that.
But then when we think about matters of conscience, your son dressing up like a pirate, your daughter dressing up like a princess and trick or treating at neighbor’s houses, a lot of times what parents do is they present their matters of conscience as if they were first rate issues. Believing that we should not dress up for trick or treating is the same as believing that Jesus rose from the grave. Completely not the same. One, believing that Jesus rose from the grave, that’s a first importance according to Paul in one Corinthians 15.
(04:54):
Dressing up like a pirate or a princess and going out and getting candy from neighbors, that’s a matter of conscience. So a lot of times we falsely give our kids this understanding that our matters of conscience that they should as children adhere to while they’re living in our houses, that our matters of conscience are of the same first importance as some of these things that are clearly outlined in scripture.
So that’s one thing I think we need to make sure we get clear in our thinking is understanding what are matters of conscience and not presenting them to our kids as things that are all Christians, all Bible believing Christians believe what we believe on this matter of conscience versus things that like avoiding participation in witchcraft, that’s clearly forbidden in scripture.
Dr. Matt Jones (05:38):
Right. And that would be an example of an explicit biblical command, right? So any other broader biblical principles that you like to bring into this conversation regarding Halloween? Because you’ve talked about explicit commands and matters of conscience. Are there other broader biblical principles that you say, “Hey Christians, you really need to think about that.”
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (05:57):
Yes. One that I think is really important, and actually it’s just been over the past, probably about five years, just as I’ve gotten more familiar with the Bible and that the longer you’re a Christian, you’re probably reading through the whole Bible every year and the Lord is revealing those truths that have always been there, but we might not have been aware of.
And as I’ve been reading through scripture over the past several years, I’ve been like, “Wow, scripture really presents death as an enemy. The last enemy to be destroyed is death.”
And in our culture, we tend to go to one of two extremes. Either we avoid all talk of death, we live in a culture that is really big on plastic surgery and other forms of just denying the fact that we are all marching towards the grave, and then we no longer have funerals.
(06:42):
We now have celebration of life services. So we just avoid all talks of death. Or on the opposite end of the extreme is we engage in death as if it’s just something to laugh at, as if it’s an entertaining thing. And both of those are aimed at trying to make us not feel scared of the fact that we are all marching towards the grave.
But scripture is very clear that Christ has defeated death. We’re all still going to walk through that unless the Lord returns in our lifetime, but death is an enemy.
(07:17):
I know that not all Christians would agree with me, but I think that when we look at scripture and, seeing that death is an enemy, that’s a biblical principle that we should apply to Halloween, that if we are engaging in it, it’s not something that we should celebrate. If we’re thinking about our kids trick-or-treating and it doesn’t go against our conscience, are we allowing our kids to dress up as something that actually celebrates death, what God calls the ultimate enemy?
So thinking through that biblical principle, there’s no thou shalt not dress thy child as a ghost or a mummy or whatever, but there is this fact that death is the enemy and as Christians, it’s not something that we should celebrate.
Janel Greig (08:00):
Yeah. It’s interesting you bring that up too. Matt and I and our producer who you met, those that are listening know him as the bearded wonder as Matt refers to him, but we were talking about just what we see in culture over the last five or so years with the decorations this time of year are very much celebrating, not everywhere, but more. You see more of that celebration of death and scary decorations.
So Elizabeth, scripture clearly condemns witchcraft and occult practices, which we just talked on a little bit, but how should parents distinguish between innocent Halloween traditions and activities that might celebrate or normalize things that scripture condemns? Do you have more examples that you can share?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (08:43):
Yeah, I think a good question that any parent can ask themselves as they’re thinking about what they’re allowing their kids and their whole family to participate in Halloween is what is the motivation behind this? Because that can reveal a lot. What is the motivation?
Do I feel uncomfortable with participating in this part of Halloween, but I’m just worried about what my neighbors across the street are going to think? Or am I going into this with a clear conscience? Or am I desiring to engage in this because this is a great way for our family to engage with the entire neighborhood and to continue building relationships, gospel-centered relationships?
Or am I allowing my child to wear this costume because most of their friends are wearing costumes like this and I don’t want them to feel left out? Or is this something my child genuinely enjoys and I have a clear conscience about it?
(09:29):
So I think actually looking at the motivation behind it can give us a much clearer answer because when you look at a certain costume or a certain, if you’re going to go out trick or treating in the evening, if you have a motivation that’s just a fear of man and oh, I don’t want my neighbors to think I’m weird, that’s not a motivation that’s honoring to the Lord.
But if you’re thinking, oh, this is a fun thing for my kids to engage in, it’s a way for us to engage with our neighbors in the neighborhood, that’s showing you that your motivation is actually a God-honoring motivation behind that.
So I think if parents can just ask themselves that question about each and every aspect that they’re considering about Halloween, that that can be a way to just gain clarity. And I think of my siblings with this and that I have two siblings.
(10:12):
I have a brother and he has four kids and a sister and she has two kids and they’re both Christians. They’re married to wonderful Christian spouses, by God’s grace raising their children in the fear and admonition of the Lord.
And one of my siblings and their spouse have decided to participate in Halloween in their neighborhood and the other sibling and their spouse have decided not to participate in Halloween in the neighborhood. And they both understand the other one has a different matter of conscience and there’s no fighting, there’s no animosity between them.
But my sibling who has decided not to engage in Halloween with their children, what they have decided to do is they think that passing out candy at their door is a good way to get to know their neighbors and to engage with them. So this sibling and their spouse, they explain to their kids, this is why we’re not going to participate in trick-or-treating.
(10:59):
And they explain that according to their conscience, they can’t do this with a good conscience because they think a lot of evil is celebrated at Halloween. However, they then explain God has called us to love our neighbors and while our neighbors are trick-or-treating, being at the door and passing out candy, this is a way we can show our neighbors that we love them and to get to know them.
So I think examples like that, it’s going to be different for every family, but so long as you’re not going against something that scripture forbids or commands and you have a clean conscience with what you’re doing, you can walk forward in confidence in that decision prayerfully knowing that the Lord can change your heart on that if he sees fit.
Janel Greig (11:38):
That’s a good point.
Dr. Matt Jones (11:40):
And I appreciate you pointing out that actually this might be a form of outreach. So I’m going to steal one of Janel’s questions. What options are available around Halloween to possibly spread the gospel that that may be another form of saying, “Hey, here’s our need for a savior.” Are there other ways that Halloween could be engaged in a way that’s redemptive?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (12:06):
Yeah, I think I’ve seen several families do this really well. One family that I know, this is just with their kids, so this is just outreach to their kids. As you both mentioned, Halloween decorations have gotten a lot darker over the past decade or so.
And so one of my friends, she’s just had her kids memorize the verse that the last enemy to be destroyed is death. And so as they’re walking through the neighborhood with their toddlers, as they see the huge skeleton coming out of the ground or the vampires or whatever it is, every time they walk past a decoration like that with their kids, they say, “Okay, what truth are we going to remember?” And they say, “The last enemy to be destroyed is death.”
So just in that moment, throughout the whole month, my friend and her husband are really reaching out to their kids.
(12:48):
They’re catechizing their kids in that we can actually use these decorations in a redemptive way to remind us that death is not a good thing. It’s not what God originally designed, but eventually it will be destroyed forever. So I’ve seen that example.
I’ve also seen, I have other friends who, they live on a little cul-de-sac, and so what they do for Halloween is they actually heat up a bunch of cider and then have apple cider donuts, and they invite their neighbors into their house.
And so their whole neighborhood knows that this isn’t just a trick-or-treat stop where you knock and you get candy, but a lot of people make it the last stop on their trick-or-treating journey because they come in and they stay, and my friend lives in the Midwest, so it’s usually pretty cold when they’re trick-or-treating. And so it’s a place to get warmed up with cider and have donuts.
(13:32):
And my friend and her husband, they just build relationships with their neighbors, and it’s not like they’re preaching the gospel right there on Halloween night, but it’s through those relationships with their neighbors that they’re able to then share the gospel throughout the year.
And then I also have another friend that what she and her husband have decided to do is they don’t allow their kids to trick-or-treat, but they do give out candy, and then they just buy a whole bunch of Halloween tracks that just… They’re not cheesy, but just talk about, why is it that we tend to like to make fun of death? It’s because it kind of scares us and then presents the gospel.
So I think that all of those examples are great ways that we can use Halloween as an outreach to our kids and to our neighbors and to those who we might not even know.
Janel Greig (14:16):
That’s great. One of the things I think I want to draw out for our listeners that you pointed to, Elizabeth, and you were talking about your siblings and how they do it differently, the family that isn’t celebrating, but they’re handing out the processing that they’re doing with their kids saying, “This is why we do that.”
So there’s not condemnation for those doing it, but there’s an understanding also of processing and that critical thinking and thinking through their faith and what God’s word says. I love that. That’s what we’re called to do with our kiddos, so that’s a very practical example.
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (14:44):
And I think that can be helpful in the long run too. As we were talking a little bit about before, helping our kids understand, what are these matters of conscience, so that they understand when I grow up, I might have a different conscience about this. I might grow up and get married and decide it’s okay for my kids to trick-or-treat, and that doesn’t mean I’m not a Christian.
So that our kids can process this so that they know if I grew up and I believe that Jesus didn’t rise from the dead, I’m probably not a Christian because that’s the foundation of Christianity. But if I decide to have my kids trick-or-treat or I decide to allow them to watch this TV show or to do X, Y, or Z, that doesn’t mean I’m not a Christian, it just means my conscience is different on that matter.
Janel Greig (15:23):
Yep. Very good. Very good. Well, Elizabeth, this is a fun part of our show where we get to know you and do some fun facts. It’s called the speed round. So if you’re up for this, the only rule for this part of the show is your answer has to be short. Does that sound okay?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (15:40):
Okay.
Janel Greig (15:41):
I’ll try my best. I know. Matt and I will just take turns asking you questions. They’re all related to… Well, I think most of them are related to Halloween, so we’re sticking with the theme. So candy corn, delicious or disgusting?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (15:57):
If it has something salty mixed in with it, I find it delicious by itself. It’s kind of sickeningly sweet.
Dr. Matt Jones (16:04):
Yeah, good. Well then in light of that, what’s your favorite candy?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (16:08):
Oh, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups when they’re frozen. I love frozen Reese’s.
Dr. Matt Jones (16:13):
Oh, that’s good.
Janel Greig (16:14):
Okay. Pumpkin carving or pumpkin painting or neither? Maybe neither.
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (16:21):
I’d say painting. It’s less messy. Okay.
Janel Greig (16:24):
Yeah.
Dr. Matt Jones (16:25):
And did you guys do costumes as a child? And if you did, did you have a favorite one?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (16:31):
Yes, we did costumes and my mom would always hand make them. I think, my favorite one, my mom made a taco costume for me. Amazing. I was dressed as a taco and she still has the costume, so she was amazing.
Janel Greig (16:46):
That is amazing. That’s cool. What do you think is the most overrated candy?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (16:53):
Oh, I do know M&Ms. I do not enjoy milk chocolate. It kind of grosses me out. So when people grab a handful, I’m like, “Oh. Okay.”
Dr. Matt Jones (17:04):
I agree with you without the peanuts, but with peanuts, that’s a different story.
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (17:09):
That is true. That is true.
Dr. Matt Jones (17:10):
All right. Pumpkin spice. Love it or leave it?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (17:15):
Leave it.
Dr. Matt Jones (17:16):
All right.
Janel Greig (17:18):
These are fun. What’s one thing people would be surprised to learn about you, Elizabeth?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (17:24):
Oh, goodness. Well, if you’ve never met me in person, this does not have anything to do with Halloween, but if you’ve never met me in person, I’m 5’10” and I often wear heels. So people are very surprised when they meet me in person and they’re like, “I didn’t expect you to be this tall.”
Dr. Matt Jones (17:37):
Okay, cool. And then a book or the best book you’ve read recently?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (17:43):
Oh, the best book I’ve read recently. This is hard. I love reading books. Okay, so the one that comes to mind automatically, it’s a really old one. Well, not really old, it’s the ’90s, but Loving God With All Your Mind by Elizabeth George. I am a thinker and the book has radically transformed my life. So grateful for that.
Dr. Matt Jones (18:04):
My wife loves Elizabeth George. That’s great.
Well, before we got into the speed round, you were talking about family dynamics and differences in conscience and how to navigate that. I was just wondering if you could press in a little bit on that to help parents or at least parents that have siblings that are also married.
How do parents navigate those different convictions regarding Halloween, particularly when other families, not just in their church, but also in their immediate family, their cousins, cousins are getting to go do this and we’re not. How do we deal with that with making decisions?
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (18:39):
Yeah. Well, there are so many different possible family situations, so I’m going to offer some general wisdom, but I would advise all families to take it with a grain of salt because you could be talking about families where all the siblings are believers. You could be talking about families where half of them are believers, half of them are not. So there’s so many different family situations.
So what I would advise is the first thing is to talk with your kids about this, and again, to talk about how this is a matter of conscience. Explain why you and your spouse have decided to let your kids engage with this or to not let your kids engage with this and explain that it’s a matter of conscience and then just outrightly explain your aunt and your uncle, they have made a different decision. Does that mean that they’re horrible people?
(19:23):
No, it means they have a different conscience on this. Does this mean that we think that our cousins are doing something bad? Nope. It just means they have a different matter of conscience on that. So I think that’s the first thing because kids tend to be very black and white thinkers, especially as they’re younger and they get stuck in that.
I taught third grade for a decade and I always would not like Halloween season, because kids in my class would just say such rude things to one another based on what the decisions their families had made surrounding Halloween.
So I think if we can first start with our kids and just explain to our kids that this is a matter of conscience, and then, I think to help make it… And again, there’s so many different family situations, this isn’t going to be possible in every family situation, but where it is possible to make it not an area of contention.
(20:08):
So if the whole family’s going to get together to trick or treat, you can explain if this goes against your conscience, this is why we’ve decided not to do this, but can we get together with you beforehand or can we get together with you after and still do something together, fun as a family?
Or similar, if you are the family who has decided you can trick or treat and you have a sibling who’s decided their kids cannot trick or treat, again, doing the same thing. Can we get together with you before or after? And maybe just saying to your kids, we’re not going to go in our costumes because we don’t want our cousins to feel bad that they’re not trick or treating, so we’re just going to go together and we’re going to have a fun fall time with them.
So I think talking with our kids and then thinking through, how can I obey the command that as far as it is possible with me to be at peace with all my brothers and sisters?
Dr. Matt Jones (20:53):
Yeah. Well, I appreciate you bringing in Romans 12 because later in Romans 14, it does allow for matters of conscience. I think it’s important to remember everybody’s going to have the opportunity to give an account for the life that God’s granted them.
And so I don’t have to fight some of those battles that are matters of conscience. I need to process and I need to discuss, but ultimately we don’t answer to one another on those. So thank you. That’s really good insight.
Janel Greig (21:21):
Elizabeth, can you talk about a little bit more regarding parents and them cultivating an environment where they can talk through and process things with their kids so that in a situation where maybe a kid really wants to go to a Halloween party that one of their friends is having and the parents are saying, “No, we don’t do that.”
How would you encourage parents to set up an environment where kids feel welcome to say, “But hey, mom and dad, what about this? Can we think about this? Could I possibly do this?”
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (21:49):
Yeah, that’s a great question. I love that, Janelle. So I think that this happens not just in the moment, but it happens over the whole course of parenting. It’s not just around Halloween, but I think getting in the habit of asking our kids questions to help us understand their thought processes, and this is so hard. There’s a reason that James had to tell us to be quick to hear and slow to speak because we’re not naturally wired this way.
Even just a few days ago, I was on a team meeting with some of my coworkers, and I had to go back and apologize to them afterwards because there was a disagreement and I was just coming in strong with my opinion rather than asking them questions to understand.
And so I think if we can ask the Lord to help grow us in our ability to ask questions and ask our kids questions just whenever they ask us if they can do something to say, “Oh, that’s interesting that you want to do that.”
(22:37):
“Tell me more. Why do you want to do this?” Or, “What is this exactly that you want to do? What are your friends saying about this? Why do you think that doing this would be a good idea?” Because when you start getting in this mode of asking questions, one, it forces your kids to have to think through what they’re asking to do and why.
It helps you understand their thought processes a little bit behind it to understand, do they really want to do this thing or are they just trying to fit in with everybody else? Do they really understand what this thing is or do they have a lot of blinders on just because of their children?
So I think just cultivating this environment where we’re consistently asking questions and that will, Lord willing, make our kids more comfortable to come to us with their questions and with ideas for things that they want to do, to know mom and dad don’t just automatically say no to me every time. Even when they say no, they ask me questions to really understand that. So to just help our kids feel comfortable in coming to us.
Dr. Matt Jones (23:35):
That’s really good.
Janel Greig (23:36):
Great tips.
Dr. Matt Jones (23:37):
I have one more question unless Janel has another one, but when it comes to this topic of Halloween, we’ve talked about it in many different ways. Is there a question we did not ask today that you say, “Wow, I really wish that they had asked this so that our hearers could think about this component of Halloween?”
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (23:56):
I think you covered everything pretty well.
Dr. Matt Jones (23:59):
Way to go, Janel.
Elizabeth Urbanowicz (23:59):
Good job, guys.
Dr. Matt Jones (24:02):
Well, that’s great. Well, as you picked up today as you were listening, Halloween can be a challenging topic for Christian families, but it’s also an opportunity to teach our children how to think biblically about the world around them, especially about the world around them where not everybody agrees.
So whether your family chooses to participate or not, our goal should be to honor God, exercise wisdom, and extend grace and mercy to those who reach different conclusions. Elizabeth, thank you. Big thank you goes out to you today for joining us and helping us navigate this conversation.
To learn more about Elizabeth and the resources available through Foundation Worldview, visit foundationworldview.com. That’s foundationworldview.com. Thank you all for listening to the Upside Down Parenting Podcast. And Janel, thanks for joining me again. Elizabeth, God bless, and we’ll see you all next time.
